Practical Green Merchandising

(This piece originally appeared in the April 2011 issues of Merchant Magazine and Building Products Digest.)

Choosing winning product lines and getting them into the hands of customers is an art that, when practiced well, makes good merchants great.  The last few years, there’s been a rush by manufacturers to get their green innovations to market.  Many are going to be clear winners and will make a difference in transforming the built environment.  Unfortunately, along with the rush has been the slapdash - products presented as earning LEED credits, or being less toxic, or ecologically benign, when they are not.  Whether by deliberate deception or honest mistake, green washing has created confusion and skepticism in the market. 

It’s not so easy to pick green winners, but there are practical steps that merchandisers can take to reliably evaluate the green-worthiness of any product.  In general, the goal is to identify merchandise that meets certain criteria, both yours and your customers’.  There are a variety of product certifications and, of course, LEED and other green building rating systems provide relatively clear criteria.  But there is no master green products list to go by, and no matter how comprehensive, certifications and building rating systems are not going to cover all the product categories stocked in most stores and yards. 

But if you’re willing to roll up your sleeves and “green it yourself”, there’s another way to look at whether the merchandise you choose to sell is green worthy.  Start by asking:  Does it harm or benefit the environment? Does it pose health risks or promote healthy lifestyles?  Are communities positively or negatively affected in its manufacture?  Does it work?  Will it sell?  These questions should take in the entire lifecycle of the product, which includes looking at the impacts relating to raw materials, manufacturing process, distribution, use and disposal. 

The broad categories addressing human health and safety, ecological safety, and social responsibility provide the background for more specific product criteria and attributes – a partial list:

• Energy – products that conserve energy, produce renewable energy or are made from renewable energy sources. 
  
  
• Water – products that conserve water usage, especially the use of fresh, potable water, also product alternatives that don’t pollute water sources or aquatic eco-systems.
  
  
• Toxic chemicals – products that are made with non-toxic or least toxic, low risk chemicals and other components.
  
  
• Healthy and sustainable practices – products that contribute to healthy and sustainable practices, such as rainwater harvesting, composting, etc.
  
  

The evaluation process starts with the manufacturer who should provide credible product information, preferably with third-party documentation supporting their green claims.  That may not be enough.  Consult with independent experts and review third-party information on the internet, too.  There are several helpful databases online that will show what’s known about specific chemicals.  Comparing products in the same category will help to identify the “greenest” in class.  Finally, there must be a judgment about whether or not the product does the job and will sell – get a sample, take it for a test spin.

If the green merchandiser is defined by product selection, he or she is also defined by products not selected.  There are plenty of useful products for which there may be better or greener options.  But there are also junk products for which the only “green” option is that they simply not exist.  Every dealer in this supply chain has experience with junk, if only by accident.  These are products so poorly designed, manufactured so cheaply, and are so obviously heading straight for the landfill that they cannot be justified no matter how low the price point.  Eliminating the worst junk from inventory is not only practical, it’s also a virtuous step toward sustainability.

8 Great Projects for Greening Operations

(This article originally appeared in the March 2011 issues of Merchant Magazine and Building Products Digest.)

Want to be leader in the green building arena? There’s no better way than to demonstrate your commitment and know how by actually implementing projects on your own facility. Anyone can stock certified merchandise. And it’s easy to put out a few green hang tags on the shelf or signage proclaiming your eco virtues, too. But to really set yourself apart from the “me too” crowd, build valuable relationships with other leaders in the industry, and save money in the process, you’ve got to walk the walk. These days, it’s a little easier than it used to be. Depending on the type of project there may be government incentives available or a relatively motivated local bank ready to finance something with a solid green profile.

1. Energy retrofit – Make your facility energy efficient with better lighting, insulation, and mechanical systems. Then add renewable energy generation, too. Undertaking this kind project will pay dividends for decades to come. In the short run, build valuable relationships with those firms doing the work. In the longer term, as energy prices continue to rise, enjoy predictably lower costs.
   
   
2. Living roof and/or living wall – Installing a living roof delivers multiple benefits, including saving energy and giving your team experience in a young, fast growing market segment. Combine with water recycling systems for additional “wow” factor.
    
3. Cool roof – If you’re not ready for solar panels or a living roof, think about this: if the roof isn’t white, you’re might be paying too much for air conditioning. Paint it white, save energy – it’s that easy.
    
4. Water recycling – At first glance, conventional financial models may not make the quantitative case for water efficiency projects – water prices are kept artificially low. But if you’re operating in a region with stressed water resources, taking steps to reduce your demand can set a powerful example for your community. There may even be rebates available. Install HET toilets, rainwater harvesting and gray water recycling systems, and gain valuable experience you can use to promote these green practices to your customers, too.
    
5. Recycling for batteries, fluorescent lights, paint, electronics, etc. – This may prove to be more difficult than it sounds, especially if there’s no local, infrastructure, but will be well worth it in the end. These products contain toxic heavy metals and other components that pollute ground water. There are a variety of programs available benefiting a range of non-profit activities.
    
6. Zero waste – Reducing the waste generated at your facility will engage both staff and customers, and may reduce your waste haulage bills, too. Remember the Three Rs will help you get there – Reduce, Reuse, Recycle.
    
7. Replace portion of parking lot with community vegetable garden and bicycle racks – Don’t discount this project as being impractical or too costly. There will be plenty of people in the community willing to lend a hand. Encouraging bicycling reduces the carbon footprint associated with your facility. Planting instead of parking does the same and can provide fresh vegetables for employees, customers, or members of the community in need.
    
8. Shorten supply chain – Sourcing product and materials closer to home reduces transport costs. Depending on where manufactured, imports may already carry a high carbon footprint because of inefficient coal-fired electricity generation. On the other hand, local products can earn LEED credits for local building projects and, generally, will appeal to a growing number of customers preferring products and materials made in the USA.

Universal Green Product Database? Yes, Please!

(This piece originally appeared in the February 2011 issues of Merchant Magazine and Building Products Digest.)

I sound like my grandpa, but today’s green merchandisers never had it so easy. Back in my day – 2005 – there were few residential green building programs or product standards to consult. Online lists and databases of verified products were sparsely populated and behind the market. When I was asked to develop a green merchandising program, it was a challenge we met only by doing lots of extra work vetting products ourselves and assembling our own database. Though our methodology would be easy for non-experts to implement, the burden on a typical merchandising department is simply too great.

Thankfully, the last several years have seen tremendous maturation in the green building sector. The trails have been blazed and today’s merchandise managers have a growing number of information resources at their disposal. But trails are trails, and until sustainability is a fully mature, mainstream superhighway, (ironic choice of metaphor, I know), successful merchandisers must still invest time in evaluating their green product choices. There is still no universal green product database. On the other hand, there are a small number of valuable online resources that make the process of identifying “greenest in class” products a little easier.

The GreenSpec database from BuildingGreen.com has been one of the most trusted sources of green product information for years. The editors evaluate products against their own stringent criteria and avoid accusations of favoritism or bias by not accepting advertising or listing fees. It’s not a comprehensive list, but the products listed are often best in class. BuildingGreen offers news and analysis, too, and is a valuable resource that every dealer and distributor in the green building space should utilize regularly.

In the recent past, a common criticism of green building rating systems organizations is that they failed to provide relevant product information, also. Wisely, both national residential green building programs are developing their own green product information resources. The NAHB is creating a database of products that the NAHB Research Center has evaluated and approved for use in their National Green Product Standard program. However, it is virtually useless at this stage with a clunky interface and only a handful of products listed.

Alternatively, the GreenHomeGuide.com, founded in 2003 and acquired by USGBC in 2008, is not a simple directory of products. The site is based on expert advice delivered as focused “Know How” pieces or as answers to inquiries in the “Ask a Pro” section. Providing this kind of contextual information about products and materials can be extremely valuable for gaining knowledge about the category, alternatives, performance, and installation issues that simple databases will not provide. While it offers no product directory, per se, it does link to the GreenSpec directory.

There are other product lists and directories worth a look, too. Product certifying organizations, such as Scientific Certification Systems (www.scscertified.com), list certified products on their websites. But the need for reliable, transparent product information is huge and still largely unmet. New online directories have emerged to try to fill the gap. One of the best designed attempts to provide a LEED-oriented directory of products is EcoScoreCard.com, but it’s still too young to be comprehensive.

Green building culture values transparency and third-party verification, which has led to greater focus on life cycle analysis (LCA) and environmental product declarations (EPD) as a standard method for manufacturers to communicate the sustainability profile of their products. If widely adopted, such standardized product data would make development of a universal database feasible. That’s exactly what’s needed in order to create mainstream scale at the retail end of the green building supply chain.

The Long View

(This piece was originally published in the January 2011 issues of Merchant Magazine and Building Products Digest.)

“In the long run, we’ll all be dead.” That unfortunate utterance from a now dead economist has provided a handy excuse for shortsighted business planners focused only on extracting the maximum profit from the here and now. That kind of thinking is responsible for many business failures, yes, but also many environmental problems more daunting even than the federal deficit. Failure to consider the future implications of decisions made today virtually guarantees a legacy of difficulty and hardship for the next generation.

Taking the long view, on the other hand, is at the heart of green thinking. Therefore, this January, I encourage you to forget about 2011’s top trends for a moment and invest some quality time considering the next decade and the opportunities and threats it will present to your business and community.

The best place to start is at the end – what will your business look like in 2020? Has it been passed down to your children? Acquired, shut down or thriving with you securely at the helm? Is it connected to the same old supply chain? Is the local economy vibrant and strong, or struggling along? Most importantly, what do you want your business to look like and what sort of realistic scenarios will lead you there? To answer these questions one must first consider the long term forces reshaping our industry.

The next decade will see plenty of change and probably as many surprises as the last. Obviously, “green building” is on its way to becoming the new normal, whether it’s LEED or another approach, creating new opportunities for growth. Transport fuel prices are trending higher with the very real possibility that periodic episodes of price volatility will devastate marginal businesses. Households, businesses and governments will continue to shift purchasing to less toxic and more eco-efficient products from socially responsible producers. Competition between “big box” chains and independent dealers will continue, with increasing activism from localization groups. The green DIY and urban agriculture movements will continue to take root across the country. And a host of global and domestic macroeconomic factors will attenuate or amplify these opportunities and threats.

But underlying whatever scenario one wants to envision for the next ten years, there is the inescapable reality that the global climate system is changing, most likely due to human activity. The last decade was the warmest on record, but more important to consider are the local and regional impacts. Damaging and costly extreme weather is becoming more common. NASA has published a slideshow depicting the number of temperature anomalies each decade going back to 1880, (earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Features/WorldOfChange/). The trend is unmistakable, which should be cause for concern, especially in the context of the massively destructive heat wave that hit Russia last summer.

Regional climate patterns are changing in ways that dealers and distributors should understand and anticipate. The US Global Change Research Program, (www.globalchange.gov), provides useful analysis for each region of the country. Depending on your location, expect more drought, more fires, more floods, more heat waves and cold snaps, and more precipitation when it comes. And when these “anomalies” occur, they will probably be at the wrong time, disrupting water supplies, agricultural harvests, supply chain logistics and more.

These broad trends suggest that merchandising and business model innovations will be required to sustain a successful business. Households, businesses and governments will be forced to invest in mitigation and adaptation strategies. Dealers will, too. But those long-term planners among them will be prepared to weather whatever the decade has in store, with solutions that will help their customers and communities, too.

Thinking Globally, Building Locally

(This article was originally published in the November '10 issues of Merchant Magazine and Building Products Digest.)

The green building movement is rooted in big thinking, but the USGBC is beginning to think small and local. Their mission is to transform the built environment – that’s thinking big with over 125 million buildings in the US, most of which are energy and water hogs. Considering that buildings account for a third of the US carbon footprint, success is of global importance. After over a decade of leading the commercial building revolution, USGBC has become a transformative force with a valuable brand. But there still remain 120 million less than efficient residential buildings, which is where action must now be focused. This is why the USBGC is putting considerable effort into boosting residential green building in concert with local leaders, which is good news for LBM dealers.

In residential building, there was already a green building movement well under way by the time LEED for Homes arrived on the scene two years ago. Local and regional residential programs have existed for years in progressive cities like Austin, Texas, whose Austin Energy Green Building program was the first in the nation. LEED for Homes shares many similarities with these programs, even though each reflects its own local conditions, both in terms of content and approach. In addition, there are alternatives to LEED, including EnergyStar, NAHB’s program, the new, (to the US,) PassivHaus approach, the International Living Building Institute, the NauHaus Institute, and a host of natural building organizations.

Given these realities, I really like the USGBC’s collaborative approach. They recognize that they’re part of a budding community of green building leaders and that there’s more than one way to build a green home. So, rather than attempt to impose their rating system, they launched the LEED for Homes Affiliate Program with the pragmatic aim of forging working relationships with many green building organizations and local green building leaders, thereby promoting the broader movement in the context of local needs.

“We’re market oriented and are looking to support and promote what’s working in each community,” Nate Kredich, USGBC’s VP for Residential Market Development, told me recently. For example, they’ve been working with North Dallas Green Built and the NAHB, developing educational materials for production builders, dealers and distributors. They’re even helping to produce a “mini GreenBuild” in the area. (By the way, USGBC’s GreenBuild is November 17-19.) In Minnesota, they’ve joined a coalition with Minnesota GreenStar, with its new-build and remodeling rating systems, and Minnesota Green Communities, which advocates for healthy, affordable housing. They’ve also launched the Green Home Guide (www.greenhomeguide.com), a website to help connect homeowners, builders and dealers with trusted information, and with each other.

In terms of economic clout, green residential building is only just finding its feet and, in any case, current economic conditions have strangled most building of any kind. But when homes start to be built again, it’s likely a great percentage will be guided by a national or regional program. “We recognize that for green home building to scale rapidly, it’s important that everyone in the value chain understand the rating systems and are well-connected with their local green builders,” said Kredich, emphasizing the value of education. They’re reaching out to support interested independent dealers, like Shaw Stewart in Minneapolis, as well as the big chains. With many more new green residential products and materials coming to market in 2011, it should be easier for proactive dealers and distributors to rise with the green home building market. If that’s true, then the USGBC’s big thinking could very soon be taking root in a community near you.

Sorting out the Recyclables

(This article was originally published in the September '10 issues of Merchant Magazine and Building Products Digest.)

Nothing says “green” like recycling, or so many people assume. Since the pioneering programs in the 1970s, it seems that now the habit has become ingrained, collection infrastructure ubiquitous, and recycling is among the greenest of virtues we Americans can claim. However, all is not what it seems. Like most issues in the realm of sustainable business and green building, there are various shades of gray, not to mention green.

In today’s green building and green consumer markets, “recycled” and “recyclable” have become the low-hanging fruit for marketers eager to pin green credentials on their products. But these attributes alone don’t necessarily signify sustainable or green in any meaningful sense. Context is everything. What kind of material? What percentage is recycled, and is it post-consumer or post-industrial waste? How relevant is “recyclable” if in fact the material is not recycled? In addition, LEED guidelines vary by application and product type, so a building material with some recycled content may or may not earn LEED credits depending on how and where it’s used. It behooves the merchandiser to dig a little deeper to determine whether these terms indicate real value or are simply a “greenwash.”

In the LBM and home improvement supply chain, aluminum, steel, glass, plastics, paper and wood are the predominant materials potentially recycled or recyclable. Aluminum, glass and steel can be used again to manufacture the same kinds of products indefinitely and can therefore be truly RE-cycled. For example, products like Maze Nails (www.mazenails.com) typically contain a high percentage of recycled steel, as do most steel products made in the USA. Generally, plastics and paper can be used again to manufacture things of lesser material integrity in a limited number of cycles, and are therefore DOWN-cycled. A great example here is Green Fiber (www.greenfiber.com) cellulose insulation, which is made from over 50% post-consumer recycled paper.

Whether a material is recycled, downcycled, or even upcycled, it’s a good thing, since manufacturing from recycled feedstock is often orders of magnitude less energy intensive than manufacturing from virgin feedstock. So, buying and stocking products with recycled content is a good thing, too, creating a market for such products and keeping the demand cycle going, so to speak.

But when evaluating products, all “recycled” and “recyclable” claims are not created equal. Post-consumer recycled content trumps post-industrial every time. Claims that don’t make this distinction should be assumed, if true, to be post-industrial. Is this still good? Yes. Is it the mark of truly sustainable product? Not always. Post-industrial recycled content is usually scraps and cuttings that may or may not be easily put through the production process again. In some cases, such as “re-grind” in the world of plastics, it’s easily reprocessed and is normal operating procedure. Generally speaking, it’s also harder to earn LEED credits with post-industrial recycled content.

The term “recyclable” is next down the list. In fact, it’s very often misused by over eager marketers and can be deceptive. If the material is recyclable in theory, but not in practice, then the claim is probably not worth the virgin paper it’s printed on. In fact, deceptive claims of this sort violate the FTC’s Guides for the Use of Environmental Claims. Where there is no recycling infrastructure, per se, a manufacturer may have a “take back” program, which accomplishes the same thing.

In sorting out products claims concerning recycled content and recyclability, manufacturer transparency and third-party certifications can help separate the green from the greenwash. It can also help to determine whether the product will meet your customer’s LEED project requirements.

Oil Dependency and the LBM Supply Chain

(This originally appeared in the August '10 edition of Merchant Magazine and Building Products Digest.)

The oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico is a huge environmental calamity, but it should serve as a wake up call for the LBM supply chain for another reason. Why? The spill will certainly have an impact on local economies and local LBM dealers. But the spill is emblematic of a much bigger issue, the end of cheap oil. And that will shape the future of this industry, bringing tough challenges and green opportunities.

Many analysts are pointing out that most, or all, of the world’s easy oil has been extracted and what’s left is vastly more challenging, energy intensive, and expensive to get – pumping oil from 5,000 feet deep on the floor of the Gulf is but one example. Meanwhile, according to a US Department of Energy report, new oil discoveries are lagging consumption. And some analysts have pointed out that the point of peak oil production may have been reached, or may be reached soon.

Peak oil, as the phenomenon is known, is based on the work of a Shell Oil geologist, M. King Hubbert, who showed that just as an oil well reaches a peak in production long before the oil deposit runs dry, so too, does an oil producing region have a peak in its production curve. Once the peak is reached, production volumes flatten out, then decline. Add the fact that worldwide demand for oil is growing, (car sales in China and India are going through the roof!), and if we are at or near a peak oil situation, then oil prices will surely rise and perhaps very rapidly.

The LBM supply chain is predicated on cheap transportation costs. When fuel prices rose dramatically during the summer of 2008, many distributors and dealers took hits to their already thin margins. While that price spike was due, at least in part, to Wall Street speculators, it provided a taste of what an expensive oil future will bring – higher transport and commodity costs, and marginal businesses going bust.

So, how can you prepare and create resiliency within your organization? First, start shifting your own product mix. Identify those products most vulnerable to rising oil prices and find better alternatives such as local and green products. This will also help you meet the rising demand for such products as the green building movement continues apace. Look especially at those solutions that help your customers, (or their customers,) become more sustainable or self reliant. Also, find opportunities to supply a greater range of need within your community or operating area. If gas prices rise dramatically, your customers will be looking for one-stop shopping.

Dealers and distributors should also be actively seeking ways to reduce gasoline or diesel use within their own operations. Electric vehicles or diesel trucks that run on locally-sourced waste cooking oil might be viable options. Increasing drop ships, from manufacturer to dealer, or from distributor to end-user, will help, too, but only marginally.

Finally, get involved in community efforts to create local resiliency to oil energy shocks. Transition US, (www.transitionus.org,) is a new and growing network of groups throughout the country – 69 at last count – aiming to find ways within their own communities to reduce their dependence on oil. Groups like these are gaining influence with local policy makers, and their efforts naturally support green building and like-minded local businesses. Your involvement will help you identify emerging opportunities, make important connections within your community, and get support for reducing your own oil dependency.